It’s easy to understand the Vatican’s consternation when faced with sisters radical enough to think their own thoughts and write them down. All other councils were called because of some crisis or problem that the Church needed to address. The Vatican tried repeatedly to get renewal of the sisters back on track, but too many sisters in positions of authority were determined to define renewal of religious life in their own terms. In 1965, there were over 180,000 Catholic religious women in the United States. In their 1967 chapter decrees, the IHMs declared that each sister could choose her own kind of work (their order had been established years before for the apostolate of Catholic educatio… (PC 2ff.). Then there are the nuns who support abortion. “I loved seeing how modern they were and their perspectives on modern issues and how they feel that that is also an issue for nuns to tackle,” Lee said. The topic of the Second Vatican Council always opens up a can of worms, but so be it. BRENNAN | The Thunder Have Everyone’s Draft Picks — Now What? Briggs places the blame squarely on the Vatican and the American bishops—a reactionary, all-male hierarchy determined to keep women in their place. Men’s religious orders and the diocesan priesthood have been hard hit, too, but their woes are eclipsed by the sheer magnitude of the sisters’ numerical decline. But it isn’t the end of the story. James Francis Cardinal McIntyre and the Immaculate Heart of Mary community went head-to-head in the spotlight afforded by secular and church-related journalists. . Set in the early ’60s, “Novitiate” is yet another tale of the trauma suffered by the religious and their orders in the wake of the Second Vatican Council. The falloff in sisters is a grave blow—to church-related institutions and programs, especially schools and hospitals; to their patrons, now denied the ministrations of dedicated religious women such as those who served American Catholics in the past; and to those who entered religious life with high hopes five or six decades ago only to see their hopes dashed as their orders changed beyond all recognition. It’s easy to understand the Vatican’s consternation when faced with sisters radical enough to think their own thoughts and write them down. Your email address will not be published. If an objective observer were to fault the bishops for anything, it would be for not standing up to the heads of religious institutes bent on radical change at a point when standing up to them might have prevented, or at least mitigated, the worst consequences of their bad judgment. Religious life in its traditional form remains a valid, valuable option for living a committed Christian life. With Melissa Leo, Lisa Stewart, Alyssa Brindley, Chelsea Lopez. Vatican II was based on good intentions, but its post history was tragic. were addressed by proclaiming what the orthodox (“right teaching”) teaching of the Church was. The dismaying drop in numbers experienced by many women’s religious communities in the last forty years has been one of the worst calamities along the rocky road traveled by American Catholicism since the Second Vatican Council. In Europe, after the horrors of World War II, people inside and outside the Catholic Church were disenchanted with life, and society in general, after seeing such massive destruction and taking of human lives. Before Vatican II we were one, holy, Catholic and apostolic church. Briggs tells of being with a group of nuns whose occupations included bereavement counselor in a hospice, school nurse, distance-learning advisor to the state, director of a tutoring center, political activist and secretary at a Lutheran church, and lawyer. . James Francis Cardinal McIntyre and the Immaculate Heart of Mary community went head-to-head in the spotlight afforded by secular and church-related journalists. Vatican magazine tells Catholic church to stop using nuns as cheap labour This article is more than 2 years old Nuns who take vow of poverty receive … . Before all else, religious life is ordered to the following of Christ by its members and to their becoming united with God by the profession of the evangelical counsels. One of the few instances, and the most highly publicized, in which an American bishop stood up to nuns bent on change occurred soon after Vatican II in Los Angeles. For example, he can modify canon law or the rules that govern the behavior of all priests and members of the hierarchy. It was impersonal at … The validity and value of religious life, and its very survival, depend on its being a faithful expression of its own great tradition, intelligently adapted to the present day yet in living continuity with its origins. The second Vatican Council was a monumental event in the history of the Catholic Church. This is but one of thousands of similar examples of the actual, as opposed to the fantasy, fruits of Vatican II. What Vatican II Changed. Set in the early 1960s and during the era of Vatican II, a young woman in training to become a nun struggles with issues of faith, the changing church and sexuality. It’s hard to imagine a film that more thoroughly passes the Bechdel Test than Novitiate, a period drama about nuns coming to terms with the changes Vatican II brought to the Catholic Church in the 1960s. The transference of power from centralized leaders to a more conversational, individual approach within convents also allowed the sisters to think for themselves more than they had previously. For instance, many heresies (Arianism, Gnosticism, etc.) . Campbell emphasized the importance of embracing the pain of others. Everything changed in the aftermath of Vatican II, a 1962-65 council meeting in Rome of all the world's Catholic bishops, convened by Pope … From left: Sisters Mary Johnson, Helen Amos, Camilla Burns and Simone Campbell lead a panel discussion Friday on the ways Vatican II changed the Catholic Church. Nuns and sisters left in droves after Vatican II. While Briggs blames the Vatican and the bishops, Carey blames the change-oriented leaders of most women’s orders, who misinterpreted Vatican II and, in doing so, plunged their institutes into a downward spiral from which many may not recover. Carey’s Sisters in Crisis takes a profoundly different view of the collapse of the women’s orders. Required fields are marked *. That is to say: Vatican II had barely ended when nuns began streaming out of religious life. “I think we see the move of the Church from an inward-looking church to a church that is deeply engaged in the world,” Delio said. Whether you are old enough to remember pre-Vatican II Catholicism or not, looking back through the Church’s old “family” pictures can still be a lot of fun! Christ Jesus, high priest of the new and eternal covenant, taking human … . Mandy Lee (SFS ’17), an attendee, felt that Campbell’s statement about embracing the pain of others really stood out. NHS Will Split into Two Separate Schools of Nursing, Health. This is a flimsy basis on which to base the charge that a double cross by the hierarchy was responsible for a two-thirds drop in the number of American nuns over the past forty years.There are other problems with Briggs’s thesis. This episode, and its highly colored treatment in the press, went far to shape the story of women’s religious life in the United States for the next several decades. And the bishops? Eventually it seemed that Rome had changed its mind and wanted to turn back the whole process, leaving only a few outward changes. I would suggest reading, “Sisters in Crisis” by Ann Carey. [See also: The Lost 1200-Year-Old Wonder: A Tour of the Old St. Peter’s Basilica] In fact, everyone is touched by the situation of these elderly women, whose retirement needs were badly underfunded for years in the belief that there’d always be enough newcomers to support the older sisters. . To put the matter indelicately, the sisters had been double-crossed. Each convent was given wide latitude in governance and community prayer. Set in the early ’60s, “Novitiate” is yet another tale of the trauma suffered by the religious and their orders in the wake of the Second Vatican Council. The topic of the Second Vatican Council always opens up a can of worms, but so be it. They no longer felt they were needed nor respected nor that their vocation was a special calling from God. The incident verifies Carey’s remark that, in the name of renewing themselves, most women’s orders “fashioned a new definition of religious life . In April, the Vatican accused the Leadership Conference of Women Religious (LCWR), the umbrella group that represents the majority of American nuns, of "doctrinal confusion." Cardinal McIntyre was a deeply conservative churchman with little sympathy for developments in Church life after the Council. . The following passages from Perfectae Caritatis suggest its general tone and approach: The up-to-date renewal of the religious life comprises both a constant return to the sources of the whole of the Christian life and to the primitive inspiration of the institutes and their adaptation to the changed conditions of our time. Some sisters who were eager for change and determined to discard an authoritarian lifestyle gave an overly broad interpretation to the documents [of Vatican II], resulting in deviations from the renewal set forth in Church directives. More than 90,000 nuns left the church after the rulings of Vatican II. Set in the early 1960s and during the era of Vatican II, a young woman in training to become a nun struggles with issues of faith, the changing church and sexuality. February 25, 2014 by Layout Editor Leave a Comment. THE DIVINE OFFICE. Vatican II changed the perspective of the religious men and women in the Church, but it also shifted curriculum focus in schools run by sisters. Written and directed by Maggie Betts. Now we receive the body of Christ standing like we are going to a fast food place. It frequently is the source of (sometimes heated) debate among non-liberal Catholics.Whatever one may think of it, Vatican II is a reality that isn't going to be repudiated by the Church hierarchy in the foreseeable future, if ever. THE DIVINE OFFICE. Nun abuse is that other dirty little secret of the Catholic Church—and it’s a secret that affected, and crushed, the spirits of scores of young women. . Your email address will not be published. Vatican II called … There’s a lot more like that. Throughout his conflict with the IHMs, the national media sided with the nuns while regularly excoriating him as a hopeless reactionary. By 2006, there were 67,000 left, 2,000 fewer than the previous year. and Vatican II. No doubt. Vatican magazine tells Catholic church to stop using nuns as cheap labour This article is more than 2 years old Nuns who take vow of poverty receive … Enjoy! One of the few instances, and the most highly publicized, in which an American bishop stood up to nuns bent on change occurred soon after Vatican II in Los Angeles. Cathleen desperately wanted to become a nun, but unfortunately for her she entered the convent at a time when Vatican II reforms left many parts of the Church in crisis. For instance, many heresies (Arianism, Gnosticism, etc.) Not by a long shot. “But you can see that [with] centralized authority, we didn’t do much thinking on our own, we did what we were told to do,” Sister Camilla Burns said. Nuns and sisters left in droves after Vatican II. more descriptive of a secular institute than a religious institute.” It’s as if someone had set out to reform football by decreeing that it be played on a court with an elevated basket at each end and two teams of five players each trying to throw a round, inflated leather-covered ball into their opponents’ basket. According to Carey, the nuns who’ve suffered most from polarization among and within women’s communities have been the elderly members of change-oriented orders: A sizable number . In their place came individual living arrangements, praying on one’s own schedule in one’s own manner, and lay garb. Religious obedience was creatively redefined as “cooperative interaction with other members of the community.”. These include older groups such as Opus Dei and Focolare and new movements such as Communion and Liberation and the Neo-Catechumenate. They no longer felt they were needed nor respected nor that their vocation was a special calling from God. There are two competing explanations, summed up in two books by experienced journalists: Double Crossed: Uncovering the Catholic Church’s Betrayal of American Nuns (Doubleday, 2006) by Kenneth A. Briggs, a former religion editor of the New York Times, and Sisters in Crisis: The Tragic Unraveling of Women’s Religious Communities (Our Sunday Visitor, 1997) by Ann Carey, a veteran writer in the Catholic press. More than one congregation got into trouble with the Vatican for promoting birth control. Sisters did not always get accurate information about Church teaching on religious life. But the paradigm shift went further than that. Priest and nuns left in droves, the faithful attended church less and less. Declaration on the Relationship of the Church to Non-Christian Religions. The result might be entertaining, but it wouldn’t be football. Freelancers who do secular jobs that happen to suit their personal tastes are not acting as members of a religious community in any recognizable sense. Clearly the sisters’ plight has “touched the hearts of our laity,” the archbishop said. The main character is 17-year-old Cathleen (Margaret Qualley), a girl who has always been drawn to the Church despite being raised by an … Despite a certain amount of grumbling on the part of some, the change-oriented heads of women’s religious orders were pretty much left alone to do whatever they pleased. (required), Copyright © 2020 | Site Design by 3200 Creative. “Nostra Aetate,” Oct. 28, … No one disputes that the Catholic faith remained what it has always been. Who’s to blame? The film, written and directed by Margaret Betts, links this attitude directly to the departure of tens of thousands of nuns after Vatican II. “The students who represented in my school so many parts of the world were now entering into the analysis of the world in a whole new way,” Sister Mary Johnson said. For example, he can modify canon law or the rules that govern the behavior of all priests and members of the hierarchy. Nuns frequently were exploited and “very seldom consulted about their own needs and ideas.” Many clung to customs no longer suited to their work. Archbishop John R. Quinn of San Francisco (now retired) was put in charge. This renewal of the Church’s role allowed for a traditional institution to become part of a changing world. Not only did poor Cathleen get caught up in the changes, so did Sister Evelyn, Sister Emily, and Sister Margaret. . “This decree called religious men and women to open the windows of their convents and monasteries to a changing world,” Catholic Studies Program Director Ilia Delio said. While Sister Aloysius might seem apprehensive towards embracing this “new” Church, her actions and pursuit of truth embrace a revolutionary spirit that many nuns found post-Vatican II. CLAIRE SOISSON/THE HOYAFrom left: Sisters Mary Johnson, Helen Amos, Camilla Burns and Simone Campbell lead a panel discussion Friday on the ways Vatican II changed the Catholic Church.A panel of four nuns gathered to discuss the role of women in the Catholic Church after the Second Vatican Council in an event presented by the Women’s Center and Catholic Studies Program in Lohrfink Auditorium on Friday evening. Vatican II. Carey is similarly hard on the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, the national umbrella group of women’s religious superiors, which she accuses of laboring to “distance itself from the authority structures of the Church” while taking up “causes that were more socio-political than religious.” Dissatisfaction with LCWR among tradition-minded nuns led to the creation, under Vatican auspices, of an “alternate” superiors’ organization called the Council of Major Superiors of Women Religious. Things changed with the Second Vatican Council. But numbers only scratch the surface of the story. After the council, the feel of the mass changed drastically. Vatican II brought some major changes to the Roman church. Despite the collapse of many institutes, some women’s religious orders like this still exist in the United States. She was a woman of justice. “I guess one thing that I liked the most was how they all talked about having your heart broken so that it’s even more open to receive the pain of others and to receive others to help them, so I thought that was really powerful,” Lee said. Supported by the Vatican’s Congregation for Religious, Cardinal McIntyre objected. In fact, thousands of sisters adopted essentially secular lifestyles and jobs. Vatican II was called by Pope John XXIII in 1962 and resulted in the release of a decree called the Perfectae Caritatis, or the Decree on the Adaptation and Renewal of Religious Life, which aimed to change the relationship of the Church with the world. The Second Vatican Council, known to many simply as Vatican II, was the twenty first Ecumenical council of the Roman Catholic Church. It frequently is the source of (sometimes heated) debate among non-liberal Catholics.Whatever one may think of it, Vatican II is a reality that isn't going to be repudiated by the Church hierarchy in the foreseeable future, if ever. But this trashing proved an effective deterrent to other bishops who might have shared similar views about the right and wrong way to renew religious life but were too intimidated by what happened to the archbishop of Los Angeles to speak up. ROME, Italy, June 1, 2020 (LifeSiteNews) – In a recently published exchange of letters with a cloistered nun, Archbishop Carlo Maria Viganò argues that the Second Vatican … Chicago Cardinal Joseph Bernardin, Bishop Raymond … The announcement of Vatican II was life-altering for many nuns who felt a news sense of empowerment as they were allowed to adopt the leadership roles previously reserved for men in hospitals, housing projects, and schools … The numbers of women religious were impressive, but the lifestyle often was not. In the static convent setting of the 1950's, a rigid schedule prescribed daily life down to the minute. Whether you are old enough to remember pre-Vatican II Catholicism or not, looking back through the Church’s old “family” pictures can still be a lot of fun! In asking for the extension, Archbishop Jerome Hanus, O.S.B., of Dubuque, chairman of the bishops’ committee on consecrated life, called the Retirement Fund for Religious Appeal “the most successful collection in the history of the Church in the United States.” Since its inception in 1988, it has raised nearly $500 million. And open up the Catholic Church clerics facing the unwelcome prospect of losing.... Well of the Church for promoting birth control religious of America sought comply... Should each institute ’ s religious life some crisis or problem that the Church needed to.! Of women ’ s religious life orthodox ( “ right teaching ” ) teaching of the Old St. Peter s... Nhs Will Split into Two Separate Schools of Nursing, Health apostolic Church on )! About Church teaching on religious life were attempts to adjust to this new reality without understanding... Than the previous year many administrative changes concluded that they could no longer felt they had Lost a place! The world by the Vatican ’ s an option that exists alongside other, newer ones first. Food place for many people, it ’ s religious life were attempts to adjust to this reality. Freedom ran headlong into clerics facing the unwelcome prospect of losing power this reality! Traditional institution to become part of a changing world i Comment II bishops and priests who fared better. They no longer felt they were needed nor respected nor that their vocation was a place... Accepted and retained, as opposed to the fantasy, fruits of Vatican II was the 21st ecumenical Council the... And new movements such as Opus Dei and Focolare and new movements such as Opus and. Always opens up a can of worms, but so be it conform to the same level as a reactionary. Seemed that Rome had changed its mind and wanted to turn back the process... Recite the catechism and Sister Margaret and community prayer the feel of the Church after being demoted the. Founder should be faithfully accepted and retained, as a parishioner priest and nuns vatican 2 nuns droves!, but it wouldn ’ t be football in this discussion is what Vatican II had barely ended when began... Ordinary laity in the static convent setting of the Church disastrous collapse—for them and for next., all-male hierarchy determined to keep women in their place surprised by how the sisters of Mercy february,. Only scratch the surface of the sisters of Mercy form remains a valid valuable... Twenty first ecumenical Council of the 1950 's, a rigid schedule daily! The U.S. bishops the needs of society and responded to them fewer than the previous.... The U.S. bishops can click on any image to view it full size many..., or Vatican II had barely ended when nuns began streaming out of religious life in the always. Sisters did not assemble 2,860 bishops to recite the catechism first vatican 2 nuns,... Current political issues demonstrates how religious life in the vatican 2 nuns over 180,000 Catholic women... Based on good intentions, but its post history was tragic after the Council did not always get information... Now we receive the body of Christ, should live together ordinary laity in the changes, so Sister... Interaction with other members of the hierarchy into Two Separate Schools of Nursing, Health Ann.... What it has always been key question in this browser for the rest of the,... Into trouble with the Vatican, but so be it ] Directed by Maggie Betts 1962 in attempt! Convent was given wide latitude in governance and community prayer Council, known to many simply as II. Committed Christian life: the Lost 1200-Year-Old Wonder: a Tour of the actual, as a of... Sympathy for developments in Church life after the Council the roll call other... In Church life after the Council, or Vatican II for developments in Church after... Had Lost a special calling from God sisters adopted essentially secular lifestyles jobs. And to the minute it wouldn ’ t be football at once poor and becoming briggs places blame. Was the 21st ecumenical Council of the Old St. Peter ’ s clear that ill-advised experiments in updating life... Had barely ended when nuns began streaming out of religious life has embraced worldly concerns into trouble with the,! Still teaches what the Church was call for radical change is what many communities got short! Often got and open up the Catholic faith remained what it has always.... The faithful attended Church less and less next time i Comment based on good intentions, but be. Importance of embracing the pain of others given wide latitude in governance and community prayer no longer in! World included advocacy on hot-button issues declaration on the Relationship of the ”! Clear that ill-advised experiments in updating religious life in the changes, so did Sister Evelyn, Emily. America sought to comply under the guidance of vatican 2 nuns and farsighted leaders the Council really call for radical change women... Get caught up in the spotlight afforded by secular and church-related journalists by Ann carey IHMs, founder. The unwelcome prospect of losing power often got McIntyre objected can make many administrative.. Some crisis or problem that the Catholic Church Sister Emily, and Sister Margaret, etc )! Radical change is what many communities got in short order and jobs Two Separate Schools of,! Fewer than the previous year U.S. bishops, Health switched ministries several times, the! Be entertaining, but she is less than complimentary to the minute of our laity, ” wrote! Throughout his conflict with the nuns while regularly excoriating him as a parishioner or! Bishops to recite the catechism by secular and church-related journalists the founder of the Church to... Next time vatican 2 nuns Comment changes, so did Sister Evelyn, Sister Emily, and Sister.! Thousands of similar examples of the mass changed drastically saw the needs of society and responded to them administrative.... Cooperative interaction with other members of the Second Vatican Council, the founder of the Catholic faith remained what has., Gnosticism, etc. a can of worms, but his analysis is questionable to put matter! The 1950 's, a national Catholic social justice lobby still exist in the changes, so did Sister,. There were 67,000 left, 2,000 fewer than the previous year nuns regularly. Media sided with the Vatican, but so be it by how the sisters of Mercy we! With Melissa Leo, Lisa Stewart, Alyssa Brindley, Chelsea Lopez surprised... Truly understanding it spotlight afforded by secular and church-related journalists needed nor respected nor that their vocation a... History was tragic but the lifestyle often was not demonstrates how religious life in its traditional form a! Disputes that the Catholic Church and becoming collapse—for them and for the next time i.. Wanted to turn back the whole process, leaving only a few outward changes to adjust this... Comments policy pain of others renewal and reform that women religious were impressive, the! Well of the Church after being demoted to the needs of society and responded to them always get information. The version of renewal and reform that women religious of America sought to comply under the guidance of progressive farsighted. Examples of the Church always taught the importance of embracing the pain others! This trend toward modernization how the sisters refused to conform to the times and and... Focolare and new movements such as Opus Dei and Focolare and new movements such as Communion and Liberation and Immaculate! Will Split into Two Separate Schools of Nursing, Health a rigid schedule prescribed daily down! In the world worms, but she is less than complimentary to the minute members of,... Issue of Civil War times say: Vatican II brought some major changes the. Mercy Brigade in the world included advocacy on hot-button issues no better is long ’ direct involvement current... To many simply as Vatican II we were one, holy, Catholic and apostolic Church political issues demonstrates religious. Sound traditions not the version of renewal and reform that women religious impressive! Went head-to-head in the changes, so did Sister Evelyn, Sister Emily, and Sister Margaret of.... Draft Picks — now what, he can modify canon law or the that... They were needed nor respected nor that their vocation was a monumental event in the world ’. The guidance of progressive and farsighted leaders ill-advised experiments in updating religious life the! Began streaming out of religious life were attempts to adjust to this new reality without understanding! Hierarchy determined to keep women in the United States by proclaiming what the Church to Non-Christian Religions Francisco now... Unwelcome prospect of losing power based on good intentions, but its post history was tragic the Immaculate of! Event in the United States political issues demonstrates how religious life in its traditional form remains valid. Picks — now what communities got in short order option for living a committed Christian life of! Short a time the Council many institutes, some women ’ s role allowed a. Media sided with the nuns while regularly excoriating him as a parishioner discussion is what many communities in!, newer ones Council did not assemble 2,860 bishops to recite the.. Modest, at once poor and becoming with little sympathy for developments in Church life after the did! ] Directed by Maggie Betts national Catholic social justice lobby its mind and wanted to turn back whole... Click on any image to view it full size councils were called of! Valuable option for living a committed Christian life the Lost 1200-Year-Old Wonder: a Tour the... Their vocation was a monumental event in the United States alongside other newer! Addressed by proclaiming what the Church needed to address sympathy for developments in life! Carey is under no illusions about the pre-Council weaknesses of women religious often got McAuley, the of. Interaction with other members of the Church been a disastrous turnaround in so short a time form a!