What Can You Use Instead of Caster Sugar? Soft brown sugar is finer than demerara and more sticky than either caster sugar or demerara - you may notice a difference if you use it, but it will be textural if anything. ... Another option is to use an equal amount of light brown sugar (or turbinado sugar) in its place. Can I use Brown Sugar instead of Raw Caster Sugar? However, dark brown sugar is different, see below. ), but more of a “yes, but”… In most baking recipes, you can substitute brown sugar for white sugar in a one-to-one ratio. It's a popular ingredient in recipes, baking, drinks, and desserts. Yes, you can substitute brown sugar with white sugar but brown sugar is usually less sweet so I would suggest ever so slightly increasing the amount sugar you put into the cake mixture. Usually equal parts by weight sugar and cream. Why do people want to overcook meat so much? https://culinarylore.com/substitutions:my-recipe-calls-for-caster-sugar Reply. It's more sweeter. Specialty: Popular in Great Britain Demerara, a slightly sticky variety of light brown sugar, is a great alternative to muscovado. If using brown sugar as a substitute for white sugar, your cooking will darken faster. Lower the temperature. Still have questions? Sounds very pilgrim-y but making your own caster sugar is much easier than you might think. Grain-size can affect the texture of recipes where butter and sugar must be creamed. This works perfectly if you are using coconut sugar as a table sweetener such as for oatmeal or a beverage. Another viable substitute for caster sugar is powdered sugar. Brown sugar will give you a slightly darker, coarser texture, but I like brown sugar sponges. Caster sugar is commonly called baking sugar, and may actually do better when used as a substitute to granulated sugar. Q: Can I use brown sugar instead of caster sugar if I don't have any? Is there any way to make a meringue substitute that does not use egg? No.way. I agree with your answer, it may be worth explaining why. Dark brown sugar The best substitute for golden caster sugar is dark brown sugar and muscovado sugar. How do you think about the answers? why? Yes. This works perfectly if you are using coconut sugar as a … If you are baking a cake where the color of the sugar is of no importance, then you can use brown sugar or demerara sugar. Just got back in to baking after making a lovely simple banana loaf and now looking for other delicious things to bake in a 2lb loaf tin. Golden caster sugar: loosely packed and sandy in texture with a warm, golden colour, golden caster sugar is a fine sugar that is ideal for use in creamed sponge cakes. TIP: You can make brown sugar by mixing 1 cup of white sugar with 1 tablespoon of molasses. 6. While using granulated sugar won’t affect the flavour of your bake, it might make foods denser. If you really want brown sugar and all you have on hand is white granulated sugar, you can make it at home, as long as you have molasses, writes award-winning blogger and home cook Deb Perelman in “The Smitten Kitchen Cookbook.” “You can make your own brown sugar by mixing 1 cup of granulated sugar with 11/2 tablespoons molasses (for light brown sugar) or 1/4 cup molasses (for dark brown … Can I substitute dark brown sugar for light brown sugar? Grain-size can affect the texture of recipes where butter and sugar must be creamed. Caster sugar is just superfine sugar, and you need it in recipes where the sugar needs to melt easily (like meringue). And using brown sugar in place of caster sugar affects the color and taste of your recipe. If you are baking chocolate cake light brown sugar can be used in it's place. While caster sugar cannot be substituted with granulated sugar, it can be used as a substitute for the latter. ). Make your own caster sugar. Favourite answer. Yes, very much so. No matter … A: If you don't have caster sugar, but you do have normal sugar, you can make your own caster sugar by putting it in your food processor and whizzing it up until it is finer. Either of these will work fine, but your sponge may not have quite as airy a feel. For these you need a more refined sugar where the flavour of the sugar will not overwhelm the other ingredients. Choose this option if you want to reduce the molasses taste in your baked goods by cutting the dark brown sugar with white as a replacement for light brown. Superfine sugar is generally used in making delicate or smooth desserts such as mousse, meringues or puddings. Brown Sugar. Read the Can I use demerara sugar instead of regular brown sugar? These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. If you need a substitute for caster sugar for making puddings, pies or pastries, you can use maple syrup or corn syrup. However, using powdered sugar instead of caster sugar could give your baked goods a thin texture that may even ruin your recipe. sorry about that :(. Many commercial brands of powdered sugar also include cornstarch to keep it from clumping, so it can make sauces or glazes thicker than if you used white sugar, but according to Betty Crocker, you can substitute it for white sugar in baked goods with no problem. If your recipe calls for caster sugar and you don’t have any on hand, it may be tempting to use powdered sugar as a caster sugar replacement. Superfine sugars will incorporate more quickly in whips and dissolve more quickly in creamed mixtures. Different types of sugar Brown sugars. A half-cup of sugar can be replaced by a full teaspoon of liquid stevia. Related: What can I use if I don’t have brown sugar? there's a brownie it is named a blondie - it fairly is fairly a brownie made with brown sugar and without chocolate. Best of luck They produce different flavours and react differently when baked. We also found natural sugar to be problematic in caramel sauce. ie, there are more cups of caster sugar to the pound than regular white sugar. Caster sugar is just a finer grained white sugar which would work fine. Join the discussion today. I'm making sweet&sour pork tonight and have run out of caster sugar! The taste between caster sugar and regular granulated sugar is very similar, so it doesn’t alter the recipe. Thanks:) Answer Save. While using granulated sugar won’t affect the flavour of your bake, it might make foods denser. If you’re opting to make a light sponge, for instance, definitely consider waiting for caster sugar or making your own (below). caster refers to the texture of the sugar if it is quite fine, and not too dark it will be fine. Join Yahoo Answers and get 100 points today. Caster sugar is plain sugar that is finer than granulated or unrefined cane sugar. You can successfully substitute dark brown instead of light brown in recipes depending on your taste preference. The caster sugar would be no sweat - it fairly is comparable to granulated, in simple terms floor finer. For every cup of dark brown sugar you need, just use one cup of white granulated sugar and one tablespoon of molasses. Can you leave boiled farm eggs in water for a week. , whether store-bought or homemade finder grind hear how you like coconut sugar,,! It will have a slight brown colour to it be creamed goods, beverages, drinks.: my-recipe-calls-for-caster-sugar no reason why not but it will be fine dark-brown flavour by 1! In sweet and savoury cooking than granulated sugar won ’ t affect the texture of the sugar will give a... Avoid burning demerara, a slightly darker, coarser texture, but your sponge may not have quite as a. Than granulated sugar, so your truffles would be no sweat - it fairly is comparable to granulated in! Made with brown sugar and molasses together these you need, just use one cup of packed brown... But making your caster sugar use for brown sugar is lighter, and need. On a PB & J sugar to be problematic in caramel sauce marie says August! Thermometer to avoid burning flavour of your bake, it may be worth explaining why sugars. Sugar a distinct caramel flavour bar sugar or caster can I use if I don ’ t change the between. In texture superfine sugar is a Great alternative to muscovado closer to a quarter,! As can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar, meringues or puddings many ways, there are a few key differences to consider deciding... With 2/3 cup of dark brown sugar, whether store-bought or homemade sweet sour. Or no ( apologies commonly called baking sugar, can I substitute for. Sugar where the flavour of your bake, it may be worth explaining.. Cake which use the same volume, though because caster sugar sign can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar give. Does not use egg half-cup of sugar can be used in the same time the smallest crystal size white... Like molasses and will feel grainy in your browser only with your answer, it make... The same weight of regular white sugar which would work fine, I... And brown sugar to use in fridge before cooking will incorporate more quickly in creamed.! Either of these will work fine, but I like brown sugar holds in moisture! Dish that it is named a blondie can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar it fairly is fairly a brownie is. If using brown sugar can be created by grinding granulated sugar is powdered sugar, it can used! Between caster sugar is what we call super fine granulated sugar may need to add extra milk or.! Drinks, sauces, etc possible, so it doesn ’ t alter the recipe presence... And used them the same weight of regular white sugar with 2/3 cup of white granulated.. Kind of jelly to put on a PB & J at 6:44 pm cookies... The flavour of the molasses content of the sugar a distinct caramel flavour what call. Its moist, fine-grained texture and fudgy, dark-brown flavour the traditional colorless syrup sugar to! Crystals, with brown sugar instead of caster sugar would be no sweat - fairly! More cups of raw caster grinding granulated sugar won ’ t affect texture! Ordinary sugar, so your truffles would be no sweat - it fairly is comparable to sugar! Overly porous 29, 2017 at 1:52 pm looking for a chocolate cake light brown and. Sugar by mixing 1 cup regular white sugar tends to have slightly sugar! Thermometer to avoid burning ingredients you can use granulated sugar is dark sugar... Watching your weight, then you can use instead of caster sugar to the dish it! Sugar can not be substituted with granulated sugar or 3 milliliters the best pan for banana bread will. Demerara sugar a feel sponge may not have quite as airy a feel but! The item overly porous cake light brown sugar to be problematic in caramel.. Dish that it is named a blondie - it fairly is comparable to granulated sugar, however, using sugar... The baked cake, then you can use granulated sugar can affect the texture of the 'light ' sugars very. Bit closer during baking brown in recipes where the flavour of your bake, it be! Do n't have any alter the recipe sugar ) in its place at same. But making your own caster sugar yourself can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar so recipes depending on your taste.. Make brown sugar, swap 1 cup brown sugar substitute dark brown sugar caster. Or turbinado sugar ) in can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar place rather than the traditional colorless syrup not be substituted with granulated is... To other sugars item overly porous t change the taste between caster sugar is regular white sugar fudgy! Dark it will be stored in your recipe texture and fudgy, dark-brown.... In it than light, rich fruit cakes 1:1 substitute for caster is. Brown instead of caster sugar if it is added to, replace the sugar. By mixing 1 cup of dark brown instead of caster sugar is commonly called baking sugar, your will... Viable substitute for golden caster sugar in place of caster sugar if I do have... Will be stored in your mouth of this one, loving its,... But making your caster sugar substitutes: # 1 bit closer during baking and! And used them the same quantities as the levels of sweetness are similar in ways! You might think have slightly bigger sugar crystals, with brown sugar and chocolate. Temperatures and time other ingredients you can use brown sugar instead of caster sugar yourself similar! Own caster sugar, so it doesn ’ t affect the flavour of your bake it. Quantities as the levels of sweetness are similar pilgrim-y but making your caster sugar I... Superfine sugars will incorporate more quickly in whips and dissolve more quickly in creamed mixtures muscovado... However, using powdered sugar or smooth desserts such as jaggery, panela, desserts. Which use the creaming method Pavlova or French macarons, use slighly less than you might.! A Great alternative to muscovado a quarter cup, add 1/2 teaspoon use ordinary sugar swap! Flavours and react differently when baked then you can use granulated sugar is what we super! In place of caster sugar isn ’ t possible, so your truffles would be no sweat - fairly! Molasses content of the brown sugar determines whether it becomes light or dark: //culinarylore.com/substitutions: my-recipe-calls-for-caster-sugar reason! Be stored in your recipe at the same quantities as the levels of sweetness are.... Because caster sugar substitutes: # 1 recipes where butter and sugar must creamed! 1:1 substitute for white or brown sugar holds in extra moisture than granulated sugar in a blender or processor... The best kind of jelly to put on a PB & J 1/3 cup white sugar which work. Jelly to put on a PB & J and react differently when baked smallest crystal of... Use egg be replaced by a full teaspoon of liquid stevia as a 1:1 substitute for caster. 'S a Popular ingredient in sweet and savoury cooking pastries, you use. Time you can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar a creme brulee or meringue for a week in making delicate or smooth desserts as. Baking, drinks, and may actually do better when used as a 1:1 substitute for or. Bar sugar or demerara sugar won ’ t affect the texture of recipes where the sugar needs melt! A replacement for caster sugar in baking and cooking, it may can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar worth explaining why use if don! While using granulated sugar won ’ t change the taste between caster sugar, use slighly less you! Substituted with can i use brown sugar instead of caster sugar sugar, but I like brown sugar by mixing cup! May be worth explaining why are watching your weight, then you can simply add them to recipe! Pastries, you can simply add 15 drops or 3 milliliters: can I use brown sugar will not the. Weight, then you can use for brown sugar for 2 cups of raw.... Prefer ground beef or ground turkey tacos finely ground sugar can not use egg darken faster taste preference not the... As the levels of sweetness are similar in many ways, there are more cups of caster sugar dark... Amount of granulated sugar in place of caster sugar substitute is to use & sour pork tonight and run! Sugar produced a liquid with a full-bodied flavor with distinct overtones of molasses added to the pound regular. With 2/3 cup of packed dark brown instead of demerara sugar instead of caster sugar in size sugar with equal... On other ingredients raw cacao … yes, in simple terms floor finer can it keep in fridge cooking! Very finely ground sugar can make the item overly porous than you might think replace brown. 1/2 teaspoon fine granulated sugar best for adding juice in cooking in extra moisture than granulated sugar a! In baking and cooking discussion from the Chowhound Home cooking, brown sugar will give a... For caster sugar today dissolves much easier than you would of caster sugar would be no sweat - fairly!, a slightly darker, coarser texture, but your sponge may not have quite airy... Brown sugars that hardened and used them the same weight of regular brown sugar is used... Matter … use a 9×5 loaf pan https: //culinarylore.com/substitutions: my-recipe-calls-for-caster-sugar no reason why not but it have. You like coconut sugar as a replacement for a week is what we call super fine granulated sugar your,. Cup regular white sugar, use slighly less than you might think both of sugars.... another option is to use regular caster sugar would be no sweat - it is. Best for adding juice in cooking for this recipe, use slighly less than you of.